Do you like games where you start with absolutely nothing, and then slowly build and advance your little empire until you're able to launch so many rockets at once that you end up with some kind of a rocket hydra? And have you ever wanted to terraform a barren hunk of rock - one constantly bombarded by meteors - into a beautiful, lush paradise that's in danger of getting overrun by frogs?
Well, The Planet Crafter might just be up your alley. It's an indie survival-crafting game that has recently been devouring all of my free time.
And the reason I find it so fascinating is because it's the perfect example of how something can be greater than the sum of its parts. Because individually, each aspect of The Planet Crafter is fine... There's really nothing wrong with it, and this isn't me setting up some kind of a surprise twist either. It's just that it never really wanders past that lovely, safe embrace of fine-ness.
And yet, from the moment I started playing I could not tear myself away until I repainted the entire planet green. And after spending some time ruminating on this in the butterfly dome, I think I've figured out why: the stuff you do actually makes a visible, tangible impact on the world around you... and apparently I'm also a sucker for 'number go up' style games.
Video version of this retrospective (~23 minutes)
Making an Impact
So what do I mean by that first part? Well, it's in the name really. You're crafting a planet. So even though building new machines is usually as simple as collecting three bits of metal and slapping them together, it feels a lot more important.
After all, you're not creating magical boxes that just generate resources for you. No, you're building something that will literally seed the planet with an atmosphere. And you even get to see the clouds slowly appear!
And let me tell you, wandering around the world and getting hit by your very first rainstorm - on a planet that used to be a dry-as-bones hunk of dirt - is genuinely breathtaking. It doesn't even matter that the visuals are kinda basic. The fact that there is rain, and that you made it happen, is what makes it so damn cool.
And the further on you go, the cooler and cooler things get. Unfortunately for me, sometimes even quite literally. Because you see, I built my first base on a flat piece of land because it felt like the perfect staging ground. Easy access to resources, a central location, plenty of space for activities - what's not to love?
Well, let's just say that I heavily underestimated how far The Planet Crafter was willing to go with the whole terraforming thing. Because somewhere after monsoon number 15, the water level had risen so much that my little base became prime beach real-estate... and then the water just kept coming. Until eventually, all I was left with was a diving attraction they'll probably sell to tourists some 20 years later.
But as much as getting my precious collection of space turds wet sucked, I can't really blame the game for it. It did try to warn me! I just... uh, forgot to check my email.
Yet regardless of how dramatic all of that sounds, it was only the start. Before long, algae started to appear in the water. Then came tiny pockets of grass, and eventually even gigantic trees which straight up reshaped the land with their roots - even going as far as to open new pathways and shortcuts.
But nothing is as cool as seeing animals finally appear. Because let me tell you, going from having a couple of sad fishies in an aquarium to having an entire lake full of them had me beaming with pride.
And that's what makes it so compelling to me. In any random survival game this would've just been me unlocking a new tier of gear with slightly bigger numbers. But instead every milestone changes the world around you in a very drastic way. Sure, it might not all have a big gameplay impact, but it's just so cool to see.
Which is exactly why I found myself playing long into the night, just to see what the next stage of terraforming would bring. And now, if I ever need to ask myself what I would prefer - sleep or frogs - I at least know the answer!

To be fair, it really is a cool frog!
Number Go Up
The second reason why The Planet Crafter hooked me so much is the very peculiar way it handles progression. It's something that I find very compelling, though unlike the actual terraforming, I do have some... grievances to share.
But let's start with the good stuff. It might not look like it, but The Planet Crafter is a bit of an optimization game. Not quite to the level of Factorio where you'll have people proudly whip out a spreadsheet detailing their plans for a new factory. But even so, in the eternal battle between quality and quantity, let's just say that The Planet Crafter is wearing a 'Quality' jersey.
What this means in practice is that instead of building fifty different machines to increase the planet's temperature, you ideally only want to build a couple of super-expensive ones that you then optimize and enhance to the point of absurdity. In fact, I'm pretty sure *this thing* would probably melt its way straight to the planet's core.
And while I can certainly see the appeal of a massive, sprawling base - I have hundreds of hours in Factorio, after all - I tend to prefer my games to be light on busywork. If you're able to construct a couple of "Planet Melter 5000s" and all of their supporting toys, there's not really much of a challenge to crafting another dozen copies. I'd much rather to move to the "Universe Melter 6000" next, and that's exactly how The Planet Crafter handles its progression.
As you go through the tech tree you unlock bigger and better versions of machines you already have, and then a couple of new wildcards that make you try different things... or just make everything more efficient. And much like Factorio, this eventually leads to you unlocking autonomous drones and the game evolving into something completely new.
Because from that point onward you don't have to hand-mix your own uranium rods. You can have drones play with the danger noodles while you get to do fun stuff like design a base that, no matter how damn hard you try, simply has no chance at looking good because some idiot built it on the side of a cliff!
My only real disappointment here is that you basically don't get to see your drones do their thing like you would in Factorio. They simply zip by too quickly - often even through walls - so you don't get much time to marvel at their work. And I mean, if you're going to have a slave army of robots at your beck and call, you'd want to see them slave away, you know?

Can you even imagine standing next to a heater THIS big?
The Awkward Midgame
As for the real problem, that would be the very lopsided progression that's seemingly designed for veterans of the game rather than beginners. Because you'd expect the game to start simple, get more complicated as it goes, and then become batshit insane once you're in the endgame and there are more drone swarms out in the world than actual bees.
But, no. Instead The Planet Crafter starts by throwing a whole bunch of different things at you, to the point where it was a little bit overwhelming. But you know what? I actually liked that, because there is no failure state and no timer hanging above your head like a cartoon anvil. You have all the time and space you need to play around with all sorts of machines, mess up as badly as you want, and just kinda figure things out as you go.
The real problem starts once you get past that early period where the game showers you in goodies, because then everything just kinda... stops. Dozens of hours later I fully understand why. My original build was kinda terrible and I didn't fully understand that I can use Rockets and Optimizers to supercharge my production. But the game doesn't really teach you this. Yeah, it shows you that these are things that exist, but usually while you're being bombarded by all sorts of different unlocks... and sometimes even literal meteors!
And so my midgame was very, very boring. I kept trying to build more machines to push things along, but it barely made a dent. It's only once I finally buckled down and started to re-examine every part of my build did I figure out a path forward. And suddenly, everything clicked. I was getting showered in goodies again, my moon buggy became twice as fast, and everything just made... sense.
Now is this stumble a gamebreaker? No, obviously. But given how many posts you'll see about beginners asking WTF are they supposed to do to advance past the midgame, I think it's safe to say that it's an area the game really could be a bit more clear about.
And since it isn't, let me give you the short version, because it's actually quite simple. It's all about Rockets and Optimizers. They give massive, multiplicative and stacking bonuses. This boosts the output of your machines to such an insane level that building compact is perfectly viable - even deep into the endgame. Quality over quantity!

The build menu can get quite overwhelming when you're still new
Planet-Sized World
But enough about boring math. Instead, let's talk about something a lot more fun - getting stuck in a planet-wide sandstorm!
As you would expect from a game called The Planet Crafter, the world you get to explore is kinda big. And in true survival-craft tradition, it's absolutely chock-full of resources for you to plunder.
Now usually this would just be a video gamey thing. After all, you won't just find 30 tons of iron lying around an open field. But, no. There's an actual reason for the surface being littered with random junk! The planet gets hit by meteors more often than my stomach gets hit by chocolate. And when the meteors shatter on impact, they leave behind little treats for you to collect!
But it's not just natural stuff like volcanoes and sand-waterfalls... uh, I guess sandfalls, you can explore. The world is littered with wrecked ships... and even a couple of alien ruins to spice things up. It's never anything too outlandish, don't get excited now. As I mentioned, The Planet Crafter mostly sticks to that comfortable "it's fine" line. But even so, no matter where you go, chances are you're going to find something cool.
But even if you've seen everything, there are other planets to explore. There's even a brand new one called Magnetaris coming in December, so the game is still being actively developed. So if you want, you can keep wandering around looking for interesting things for quite a while.
The Planet Crafter also does something here that I really, really like. It makes rare materials actually rare, so you have to go out of your way to explore and find them. And since each rare material has a region - or a couple of regions - where you can find truckloads of it, it makes exploring every nook and cranny really worthwhile.
Which then, naturally, gets you into a whole bunch of misadventures. Maybe you'll tumble down a volcano and then spend a few nerve-wracking minutes desperately trying to climb up before you choke to death... hypothetically, of course. And whenever one of these detours leads you to striking gold, like finding a cave full of super alloys in the early game, it's like Christmas and your birthday rolled into one!

There's always something cool to find
A Moment to Breathe
But this is where The Planet Crafter gets a bit weird... again. Before you manage to cultivate a breathable atmosphere, you'll need an oxygen tank to... you know, not die. And much like Subnautica, that air meter is both your early game guide and limiter. Except, unlike Subnautica, unlocking a vehicle doesn't actually get you a portable source of oxygen... at least not early on anyway.
So for a good chunk of the game, you're forced to run around with only a few minutes worth of air. And since the planet is well, planet sized, you would think this would make exploration a truly harrowing experience. But... it really doesn't.
You see, you don't actually have to carry bulky and expensive oxygen canisters. You just need to bring my patented "ITS 123" technology - 1 Silicon, 2 Titanium and 3 Iron. With that starter pack you can create an ugly little shit-shack that completely restores your oxygen. And since resources are bloody everywhere, this means that running out of air isn't actually an issue. Just pick up a few random rocks off the ground and voilà, ITS 123.
Needless to say, I'm not a big fan of this. Partially because having the entire landscape dotted by 1x1 square boxes looks stupid, and mostly because it's a boring solution to a potentially really interesting problem.
Because when you're exploring the innards of a ruined starship, all of which are dark, maze-like nightmares, oxygen becomes an actual gameplay element. Suddenly that little air meter becomes a real source of stress, a source of tension, something you're constantly looking at. It makes what would otherwise be a very simple smash & grab into something a bit... more.
And that's exactly why I find it so strange that the game just makes oxygen a complete non-issue. It's a genuinely interesting survival mechanic, and it makes a lot of sense. I mean, we're stuck on an alien planet with no atmosphere. Of course oxygen will be an issue. I mean, Subnautica was like RIGHT THERE to copy from.

These little oxygen huts are a blight upon the land
Strange Scenery
And speaking of atmosphere, this is where I have a bit of a complicated relationship with The Planet Crafter, and especially its visuals.
Because on one hand, the game can go incredibly hard with its presentation. Getting caught in a massive sandstorm, with the Sun slowly getting blotted out and all landmarks slowly disappearing, is genuinely scary. And for a game where your biggest threat is occasionally forgetting to breathe, that's quite the achievement.
But on the other hand, the world itself can feel a bit too... sterile. It's almost too clean, too tidy to really sell the fantasy of being stranded on a dangerous alien world.
Maybe this is just me coming hot off Team Fortress 2 which is a wonderfully stylized game, but The Planet Crafter just feels like it's stuck between trying to be a realistic and cartoony. And just like two people trying to go through a door at the same time, it's kinda gotten it nowhere.
Now don't get me wrong. It's not ugly. The environments are perfectly pleasant to look at, and the weather effects can even be quite impressive. But even on maxed out settings, I can't help but feel that there's something missing. Some key element that just ties everything together and makes the planet feel like an actual character, especially early on while it's still a hunk of dry rock.
That said, I don't think this is a particularly serious problem. I'm not playing The Planet Crafter to ogle rocks - that's why I have Deep Rock Galactic. I'm playing it because I want to make a drill that can pierce the heavens... and also the whole terraforming thing.

Those sandstorms are no joke!
A Mix of Joy and Horror
But where The Planet Crafter gets really bizarre is the audio... and not for the reasons you'd expect. I mean, a chill exploration & crafting game needs an equally chill soundscape. Something you can kinda half-listen to while you spend twenty minutes failing to assemble an automatic poop machine... don't ask.
And that's exactly what you get. The music is generally upbeat, with that optimistic spacey atmosphere you'd expect from a game like this. I don't know squat about music theory so I can't critique it with any sort of depth, but it feels appropriate, and... well, I like it!
Most of it, anyway. Because every now and then the game slips, falls and smashes its elbow right onto the 'horror' button. You'll be peacefully flying around, collecting rocks, and then BRWOOOOOOO. *clip* The game just starts pumping out these weird bassy, droning, moaning noises that sound like a frikkin facehugger is about to jump on your head.
But there's nothing there. There's never anything there! This is a game with no enemies. The scariest thing you'll see is this frog, and it's just kind of a cool frog.
I have no idea what these particular sound cues are trying to accomplish, but whatever they're going for, they've done a pretty good job of making me NOT want to find out what they're hiding.

Is The Planet Crafter Worth Playing?
And that's pretty much The Planet Crafter in a nutshell. It does a lot of really cool things, a couple of rather bizarre things, and a few that even make me scratch my head in confusion. And yet, it all comes together to create something that is vastly better than the sum of its parts.
Because individually, none of the systems I talked about are that extraordinary. The crafting is simple, the exploration straightforward, and the progression is pretty much what you would expect. But when you mix all of this together into a stew, it becomes a genuinely satisfying experience. There's just something really special about watching all your hard work slowly but surely make the world better. If only that's how it worked in real life, eh?
So, would I recommend you follow in my footsteps and give terraforming a try? Yeah, absolutely!
Just don't go into it expecting the next big survival-crafting masterpiece. The Planet Crafter is a very simple, very casual, and very relaxing game. And that's kind of the point, and kind of the reason why I like it.
Because sometimes you don't want a game that asks you to solve complicated puzzles while kicking you in the shin. Sometimes you just want to collect rocks, build drills, and watch frogs slowly cover every inch of the surface. I'm not sure if I'd call it a paradise, but I'm certainly proud of it!